Just two years after his re-election to the Presidency with the largest margin of votes in American Presidential history, Richard Nixon would resign in 1974 amidst the Watergate scandal. The actions of the President and his White House staff left the nation reeling, a corruption of trust from which they might never have recovered to this day. Vice President Gerald Ford would pardon Nixon, an act which might have cost him the election which saw Jimmy Carter become the President.
Movies were never better than they were in the seventies. With taboos gone, filmmakers were free to create films about anything they desired, thus drug addiction, divorce, prostitution, mental illness, homosexuality, impotence, psychosis, and Vietnam found their way into films through the decade. Nudity and profanity became common place in film, replicating life.
Cinema enjoyed one of its most productive decades, not only from an artistic point of view but at the box office as many films made tens of, and eventually hundreds of millions of dollars, unseating one another through the decade as top grossing films of all time. A new breed of director emerged, one educated in cinema, with a strong love of cinema to go along with their fresh new ideas about the medium. Francis Ford Coppola would have a decade unlike any other director in movie history, directing four films, all of them among the best of the decade, he would produce another for George Lucas that altered pop culture history, and win his first Oscar for writing Patton (1970). IN addition to two awards as Best Director from the DGA, Coppola would receive two other nominations thus nominated for every single film he directed in the seventies. Among the other young filmmakers to emerge were Lucas (American Graffitti, Star Wars), Martin Scorsese (Mean Streets, Taxi Driver), Steven Spielberg (Jaws, Close Encounters of the Third Kind), Brian de Palma (Phantom of the Paradise, Carrie), along with Robert Altman (M*A*S*H, Nashville) Hal Ashby (Shampoo, Coming Home), Michael Cimino (The Deer Hunter), Sidney Lumet (Dog Day Afternoon, Network), Sydney Pollack (Jeremiah Johnson, The Way We Were) and Alan J. Pakula (all the President’s Men).
And of course there was a second coming of method acting, an explosion of talent which saw some of the finest acting ever put on the screen from artists such as Jane Fonda, Marlon Brando, Al Pacino, Jack Nicholson, Robert de Niro, Jill Clayburgh, Sally Field, Marsha Mason, Dustin Hoffman, Gene Hackman, George C. Scott, and Liza Minnelli to name a few.
One word of warning, you will not find Star Wars (1977) on this ten best list, though it would make the top twelve. In honesty, I love the film, but felt that The Empire Strikes Back (1980) surpassed the original, so you will find that film among the best of the eighties. Star Wars (1977) was revolutionary, startling, wildly entertaining and a film unlike any we had ever seen before, and truly I love the picture, but I do not believe it is among the ten best of the seventies.
THE TEN BEST FILMS OF THE SEVENTIES (1970-79)
1. THE GODFATHER PART II (1974)…Francis Ford Coppola resisted making the sequel until they offered him complete control over the film and a million dollars to make it. Going back to the book, he would bring to the film Vito Corleone’s past, casting a younger actor, Robert de Niro in the young version of the character Brando made famous, and would move into the fifties to show MIchael (Pacino), now in Las Vegas, ruthlessly consolidating his power, but losing everything and everyone near and dear to him. The picture explores how absolute power corrupts absolutely, and through Pacino’s finest performance we see Michael, his eyes cold and dead, routinely wiping out his enemies and banishing his wife Kay from his life after learning she had an abortion, slowly losing his soul. Pacino has never been better than he is in this magnificent film. And De Niro as the young Vito?? Imagine the weight on this young actor having to portray a younger version of a character now in the American lexicon of pop culture, a role played I might add by perhaps the greatest living actor at that time? Yet he does it, nailed it in fact, from the raspy voice, hand gestures, to the suggestion of danger, something both he and Pacino radiate without saying a word. Outstanding supporting work from Robert Duvall, John Cazale, Lee Strsberg, Diane Keaton, Talia Shire, and Michael V. Gazzo make this what it is, which is simply, the greatest American film ever made, and it goes without saying, Coppola’s finest hour. The film is possessed of a grand epic sweep as the immigrants arrive at Ellis Island, yet remains a startling character study of men who make their living through crime. Six Academy Awards including Best Picture, Best Director and Best Supporting Actor, for De Niro.
2. THE GODFATHER (1972)…What is remarkable when watching The Godfather (1972) again is that Brando has perhaps thirty minutes of screen time in a film that is three hours long, yet he dominates the film even when not onscreen. His presence is felt by both the audience and the actors onscreen, and we ait anxiously for his scenes, for him to come back. As the seventy year old Don Vito Corleone, Brando was electrifying, creating a character whose business just happens to be crime. The old man has taken the American Drea, and made it perverse, warped it, as an immigrant who came to this country with nothing and yet found enormous wealth and power, through criminal activities. As good as Brando is, and he is sublime, the film belongs to Pacino, who we first see as an idealistic young war hero, but over the course of the picture will become a cold blooded killer, and eventually take his fathers’ place as head of the family Corleone. Subtle yet with quiet brilliance, Pacino becomes the godfather of the title. Surrounded by excellent supporting performance from Robert Duvall, James Caan, Richard Castellano, Diane Keaton and John Cazale, the two godfathers would create one of the greatest ensembles in American film history. A masterpiece, three Oscars, yet how did Coppola lose Best Director?? Years after we are still asking.
3. APOCALYPSE NOW (1979)…Emerging from the theater after seeing Apocalypse Now (1979), opening day in 1979, I remember sitting on a bench on the street, my body shaking, stunned by the visceral experience of the film, and taking stock of my life. One thing for certain, I no longer wanted to be an actor because I knew I was incapable of the art I had witnessed within the film. Looking around I wanted to tell people about the film, to grab them and sit them down, to discuss with them the experience I had just had, to celebrate the wonder of the cinema, which led me to film criticism. From the moment that gentle swaying jungle exploded into the inferno of Viet Nam, through to Kilgore’s strutting around the beach loving the smell of napalm, to Brando’s whispering “the horror, the horror” the film had me in a grip unlike any other film I had ever seen. A surrealistic journey into Viet Nam, but also into the dark hearts of mankind, the picture made demands on its audience, yet offered a journey worth those challenges. Nothing prepares us for what Willard finds when he comes face to face with Kurtz, now a shell of the man he was, or has he in fact, become a better man? Martin Sheen was superb as Willard, the young Captain sent to kill another American in Viet Nam, the ultimate madness. Robert Duvall, pure genius as the fearless Kilgore (love the name) and Brando, haunting a the man war has slowly eroded into madness, or good sense? The cinematography in the film won a richly deserved Oscar the first of three for Stararo, yet there should have been more. How did Kramer vs. Kramer (1979) a very good film, win Best Picture and Best Director over this daring American masterpiece? I will never understand that.
4. A CLOCKWORK ORANGE (1971)…Seething with rage. That is the first impression I had the first time I saw Alex (Malcolm MacDowell) staring out at us at the beginning of this most unusual film experience directed by the gifted Satnaley Kubrick, and let me say from the very beginning, that I consider this Kubrick’s very best work. What makes A Clockwork Orange (1971) such an astounding experience to this day is that the future created in 1971, forty-one years ago, still seems futuristic to me, could be the future, and the film still has that same urgency, something many lose to the passing of the enemy time. Malcolm MacDowell gave the performance of his life as Alex, the leader of the Droogs, a group of punks who go about terrorizing the streets of London. Finally caught he undergoes an experimental treatment that takes his ability to choose right from wrong, which brings the whole thing under the attacks of the so called bleeding hearts. Once back into society Alex will relive his earlier life, coming into contact with nearly everyone he ever hurt and wronged, an irony that will lead him to great reward. Kubrick’s roaming camera gives the film an inner energy, yet more so MacDowell’s performance gives the film a jaunty feel that defies its subject matter. Like a car wreck there are times we should look away…but cannot.
5. ONE FLEW OVER THE CUCKOO’S NEST (1975)…The only word that describes Jack Nicholson’s brilliant performance in this film is to call it breathtaking. Nicholson was never better than he was here as R.P. McMurphy a small time crook doing jail time who fakes mental illness to get a cushier time in custody. Little does he know that he has now been committed by the state, and they can keep him as long as they like, until they believe he is safe enough to be let back into society. The hospital is run like a microcosm of society, run with an iron fist by Nurse Ratched (Louise Fletcher), a woman who enjoys her work which involves emotionally and metaphorically castrating men on her ward. She can whither with a glance, and the men live in morbid fear of her, except McMurphy who goes after her. As she sees his influence over the men growing, sees the men following him, she grows nervous, and though there is a chance to send him back to jail, she wants him kept, in a sequence that is chilling, because you have to ask…why? She cannot control him, he disrupts her ward…why keep him? Well, we find out. McMurphy will become the saviour of the men, but sadly as a spirit, as it is his friend the Chief that sets him free after he has been rendered harmless. Nicholson won his Oscar, as did Fletcher, but the acting around them was equally superb with Brad Dourif stunning as Billy Bibbit, Will Sampson brilliant as the Chief and Sydney Lassic haunting as the weak Cheswick.
6. TAXI DRIVER (1976)…Travis Bickle is a time bomb of destruction, a simmering cauldron or rage. Martin Scorsese’s seething portrait of a man slipping into utter madness is a journey into hell, acted with stunning force by Robert de Niro, Jodie Foster and Harvey Keitel. De Niro is Travis Bickle, a Viet Nam veteran, struggling with insomnia, who takes a job as a cab driver, going into all the toughest places in the city This was the New York before the clean up, before it became what it is now, when Times Square was a sewer of prostitutes, drug pushers and massage parlors. There, his obsession to clean up the city escalates and urban alienation never was as terrifying as it is within this picture. When his relationship with a blonde campaign worker for the latest senator fails, Travis slips further into madness and targets the senator for assassination. When that fails he attacks the pimps holding a 12-year-old girl as a hooker. Having befriended the girl he becomes a dark avenging angel, allowing his rage to explode in a carthetic a sea of blood, that is as much about saving the girl as it is about having to do something, anything. Incredibly, Travis is elevated to hero status by the newspapers for saving the girl, but at the end of the film, we see his eyes in the rear view mirror, as mad as they ever were, and understand, the time bomb has begun to tick again.
7. CLOSE ENCOUNTERS OF THE THIRD KIND (1977)…”It was like seeing God”, the lady told the news crews as we emerged from seeing the film in Toronto, my brother and I. We looked at one another and smiled, tears still brimming in our eyes at what we had seen on the screen, and knew she had seen the film we had, felt the same way we did. Spielberg gave us a film filled with wonder, allowing us to feel awe at what we saw, as man-made contact with aliens for the first time in known history. If it were to ever happen, is this not how it should? These aliens did not contact us to destroy the earth, but rather to let us know they were out there, to return some of the people they had taken, and to remind us, we are not alone. Richard Dreyfuss was excellent as Neary, an ordinary man struck with a vision and then an obsession after a UFO sighting. His journey will alienate him from his wife and children, but take him and many others to Devil’s Tower in Wyoming, where mankind is preparing to make contact. The last forty-five minutes of the film are astonishing in their innocent beauty as we come face to face with an intelligence vastly superior to ours, and who communicate with a smile and sign language used to teach music to the deaf. Just remarkable, and so full of hope for the human race, humanity all living things. That said, it is still Spielberg’s most naïve film, sadly, but a masterpiece nonetheless. He admits the film dates him, because as a father he would never commit the act Dreyfuss does within the film when he leaves his wife and children to journey into space. Yet actor and director sell the decision with that beautific look of absolute joy on Dreyfuss’ face as he walks into the ship, at last at leace with himself and the universe.
8. ALL THE PRESIDENT’S MEN (1976)…Based on the best-selling book by the two reporters who broke the Watergate scandal, Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein, this brilliant film, directed with detective like precision by Alan J. Pakula, makes sense of the myriad of facts and information that made up the scandal. Robert Redford bought the rights to the book when he heard about the men writing it and actually played a role in the execution of the style of the book, making it clear to them that they were the story as much as Watergate. With grim fascination we watch as Woodward (Redford) and Bernstein (Dustin Hoffman) dig into something that appears a routine burglary and becomes a crime that will see the President resign in shame. As Washington Post editor Ben Bradlee, who had everything to lose by standing by his reporters, Jason Robards is magnificent, winning an Oscar in the process for Best Supporting Actor. One image will forever stay with you, that of the two reporters in the Library of Congress, going through cards to see who might have had a book, and the camera pans up and up and up until we see them as tiny specks in Washington, fighting a massive machine. The film won the NYFC Awards for Best Film and Supporting Actor, as well as the National Society of Film Critics Award as Best Film. Oscar, sadly, chose…differently.
9. MANHATTAN (1979)…There are those who believe Annie Hall (1977) is Allen’s best film, but I disagree, selecting Manhattan (1979) as his best, and one of the best of the decade. This black and white valentine to New York and love is a very funny, but equally moving love story, involving several characters whose lives will intersect. Isaac (Allen) is a writer dating a seventeen year old high school girl, Tracey, portrayed with winning charm and great wisdom by Mariel Hemingway, the smartest character in the film which is populated with intellectuals. Mary, portrayed by Diane Keaton is terrific as the caustic, neurotic woman Allen believes he is in love with, so he breaks the teenagers heart to be with her, and is then never happy. Of course he will realize too late what he had with the girl, but it is she who gives him hope, asking him “to have a little faith in people”. Hemingway got a well deserved Oscar nomination for her supporting performance, but the Academy strangely snubbed the film for Best Picture, Actress and Director. New York looks better in black and white, it seems to romanticized the city, making it worthy of Allen’s deep affection and obsession. The greatest comedy of the decade.
10. AMERICAN GRAFFITTI (1973)…Without sounding condescending (and I so do not mean to do so), this film may mean something to you as you grow older. There is something about the powerful ending, telling us the fate of the teenagers that gives the picture a strength and melancholy it might not otherwise have. Think about the people you went to high school with, think about who is left, how they died, what their lives were. Beautifully acted and directed, the picture will be instantly familiar to anyone who grew up in a small town. I did, and Friday night we filled the car with gas, for five or six dollars and cruised all night, the music pouring out of the vehicles into the night. It was incredible. Friends knew where to find you, we did not cause any trouble, we just hung out with people who meant something to us. George Lucas has created a film that is about his life growing up in a small town, populating it with the characters he knew, that we all knew from high school. Ron Howard and Cindy Williams are the class president and head cheer leader, destined for marriage, while her brother Kurt is the class brain, a writer. One of his good friends is John Milner, twenty-two and still living in the past where as a teen he mattered. Terry the Toad is the geek, desperate for a girl, who he meets in Candy Clark’s dumb blonde. Paul LeMat, Charlie Martin Smith, Candy Clark MacKenizie Phillips (that one!), and Dreyfuss are all terrific. And that score, man those rock and roll tunes!!!! The film kicked into high gear a nostalgia craze that saw the soundtrack sell millions, bring about a renewed interest in the music of the Beach Boys and Buddy Holly, saw TV shows like Happy Days and Laverne and Shirley become hugely popular, and reminded us of our youth. We knew these people, hell, we were these people. A bittersweet ode to America in 1962, before innocence was forever taken away. The best film Lucas has ever made.
RUNNERS UP:
- CHINATOWN (1974);
- STAR WARS (1977);
- THE CONVERSATION (1974);
- FIVE EASY PIECES (1970);
- BLACK SUNDAY (1977);
- NETWORK (1976);
- JAWS (1975);
- BARRY LYNDON (1975);
- THE LAST DETAIL (1973);
- THE LAST PICTURE SHOW (1971);
- CABARET (1972);
- THE SHOOTIST (1976);
- COMING HOME (1978);
- HAIR (1979);
- YOUNG FRANKENSTEIN (1974)
Related Stories:
Tags: All the President's Men, Francis Ford Coppola, Manhattan, Martin Scorsese, Steven Spielberg, Taxi Driver, The Godfather, The Godfather Part II
27 Comments












For me it goes like this:
1. Annie Hall
2. Young Frankenstein
3. Taxi Driver
4. Manhattan
5. Star Wars
6. Blazing Saddles
7. A Clockwork Orange
8. One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest
9. The Last Picture Show
10. Apocalypse Now
Joey Magidson(Quote) (Reply)
1. The Godfather Part II
2. The Godfather
3. Network
4. One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest
5. Chinatown
6. A Clockwork Orange
7. Kramer vs. Kramer
8. Paper Moon
9. The Goodbye Girl
10. The Boys from Brazil
Joe G(Quote) (Reply)
The 70s were such an interesting era because it seems to be representative of cinema as a whole and the turning point towards modern cinema: blockbusters, auteur vehicles, indie films…everything done well in one frame of time. My top 10 would look like this:
The Exorcist
Monty Python and the Holy Grail
Apocalypse Now
Alien
Cabaret
Carrie
Chinatown
Network
All That Jazz
The Omen
Terence Johnson(Quote) (Reply)
Very good list. I like your statement, “Movies were never better than they were in the seventies.” Indeed. For me, the seventies is the best decade for film, by far.
My list is very rough, but here goes…
1. A Clockwork Orange (1971) (my favorite film)
2. The Devils (1971) (my second favorite film)
3. Tommy (1975)
4. The Killing of a Chinese Bookie (1976)
5. Amarcord (1973)
6. Eraserhead (1977)
7.Taxi Driver (1976)
8. Annie Hall (1977)
9. Chinatown (1974)
10. Don’t Look Now (1973)
Honorable Mentions:
Badlands (1973)
Days of Heaven (1978)
The Godfather (1972)
Harold and Maude (1971)
Monty Python and the Holy Grail (1975)
One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest (1975)
Picnic at Hanging Rock (1975)
Straw Dogs (1971)
A Woman Under the Influence (1974)
Young Frankenstein (1974)
Criterion10(Quote) (Reply)
The 70s is by far the best decade for movies in my opinion and I wasn’t even alive then to enjoy them in the theater. I also agree that The Empire Strikes Back is better than Star Wars, I’d even say much better. My top 10 would be:
1. Apocalypse Now
2. One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest
3. Dog Day Afternoon
4. Chinatown
5. Paper Moon
6. Deliverance
7. Alien
8. The Last Detail
9. The Rocky Horror Picture Show
10. The Bad News Bears
I’m looking forward to seeing your list for the 1980s because that has to be the oddest decade for film. There are only a handful of best picture nominees from those years that I would consider classics.
Jeremy DC(Quote) (Reply)
Hhmm…I just realized that I have seen fewer films from the 70s than any other decade in film (except perhaps the 20s). Oh well, that just means I have a lot to look forward to. Here are some of my favorites from what I have seen.
1. Star Wars (1977)
2. The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (1974)
3. The Godfather (1972)
4. Fiddler on the Roof (1971)
5. Jaws (1975)
6. Taxi Driver (1976)
7. The French Connection (1971)
8. Alien (1979)
9. The Godfather: Part II (1974)
10.Halloween (1978)
11. Barry Lyndon (1975)
12. Chinatown (1974)
13. One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest (1975)
14. American Graffiti (1973)
15. Days of Heaven (1978)
Steve Glansberg(Quote) (Reply)
Definitely the best decade of movies ever.
1 – The Godfather
2 – The Exorcist
3 – Taxi Driver
4 – The Godfather: Part II
5 – The French Connection
6 – The Sting
7 – Jaws
8 – Blazing Saddles
9 – Alien
10 – Halloween
Awesome(Quote) (Reply)
I’m surprised that Chinatown – a film you once cited as possessing the finest screenplay ever written – didn’t crack your top ten.
But I’m even more shocked that Nashville not only failed to be one of your honorable mentions, but that not a single reader so far has put it in their own top tens in the comments! Am I really in such a minority of movie lovers who finds that a miraculous piece of work?
Robert Hamer(Quote) (Reply)
Chinatown nearly made it as you can see — it was tough for it not to be there as well written as it might be — Dunaway weakens the film for me — and Nashville (1975) I believe is an over rated mess — the making of the film went something like this, show up, smoke some dope, shoot some film, break for lucnh smike some more, shoot some more…and so one…they were fortunate Pauline Kael praised the film before it came out — never worked for me.
John H. Foote(Quote) (Reply)
Oh John, this is worse than Jack Bauer torture having to choose ten favorites from the 1970s…but here goes!
1. Star Wars (1977)
2. The Godfather (1972)
3. One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest (1975)
4. Halloween (1978)
5. Alien (1979)
6. Carrie (1976)
7. A Clockwork Orange (1971)
8. Taxi Driver (1976)
9. The Stepford Wives (1975)
10. Logan’s Run (1976)
Honorable Mentions: Godfather Part II, Network, Jaws, The Conversation, Apocalypse Now, Blazing Saddles, A Woman Under the Influence
Most overrated/Worst 70′s “classic”: Spielberg’s ‘Close Encounters of the Third Kind.’
Most underrated: *tie* The Stepford Wives/Logan’s Run (check them out — great 70′s sci-fi)
Joseph Braverman(Quote) (Reply)
I anticipate my list being quite different here…
1. Patton
2. Rocky
3. Jaws
4. The Outlaw Josey Wales
5. Carrie
6. Taxi Driver
7. Alien
8. The Last Picture Show
9. Kramer vs Kramer
10. Days of Heaven
Something like that. Star Wars probably the most unlucky to miss out. Godfather 2, The Deer Hunter, Apocalypse Now etc I do really like but not quite enough for a top 10.
Jim Wilson(Quote) (Reply)
“Yet how did Coppola lose Best Director?? Years after we are still asking…” In a year when Cabaret took home 8 Oscars, I don’t think anybody is really that shocked about that (especially considering Cabaret is a fantastic film and one every bit as deserving as The Godfather). Seriously, John, as good a writer as you are, I sometimes think your Oscar-related hyperbole tends to weaken some of your articles. Excellent list, though! I also believe Manhattan is a better film than Annie Hall, at least one that resonates with me a lot deeper (especially that opening voice-over, as a writer, I relate to that).
I would put Chinatown at the very top of my list for 1974 and I actually think Faye Dunaway is every bit as good as Jack Nicholson, creating a character that can feel dangerous and vulnerable. I would personally put Network on the list as well, but the 1976 films that are on the list are also outstanding. I would also put The Last Picture Show inside the list (a film I find incredibly melancholic and so moving, even though I didn’t live through the 50′s or the 70′s). I love your mention of American Graffitti though, and also Close Encounters of the Third Kind.
Yes, the 1970′s is probably the best decade in the history of cinema….
Isaac(Quote) (Reply)
“they were fortunate Pauline Kael praised the film before it came out…”
Wait, what does that mean? Do you honestly think everyone secretly “knows” that Nashville is a “bad movie” but just blindly follow her opinion?
Using that logic, everyone would have dismissed films like Badlands, A Clockwork Orange, and The Piano. I hope you would have a slightly higher opinion of your peers than that…
Robert Hamer(Quote) (Reply)
No love for the Muppet Movie? Haha. Perhaps I’m a bit too in love with the Muppets for my own good. I have a list of “great 70′s films” I need to watch still, but based on what I have seen, my list is something like…
01. Taxi Driver
02. Apocalypse Now
03. Chinatown
04. Annie Hall
05. The Muppet Movie
06. Alien
07. Blazing Saddles
08. A Clockwork Orange
09. One Flew Over The Cuckoo’s Nest
10. The Exorcist
Rocky
Star Wars
The Stepford Wives
Harold & Maude
Young Frankenstein
Jedgentry(Quote) (Reply)
Missing my point Robert — and way out of line to attack my opinion of my peers considering you do not know it — this because I disagree with you and make a point, a historical point about Nashville (1975) — Kael saw a very early cut of the film and began championing the film before its release, quite some time before its release — then her minions fell in behind her, and equally championed the film — go back and read reviews from that period, Nashville (1975), like Badlands (1974), A Clockwork Orange (1971) and The Piano (1993) had their detractors, as most films do — I saw Nashville (1975) when it came out in ’75 and was not impressed, and saw it again recently, and though I admire the performances of Lily Tomlin and Ronee Blakley, I do not believe the film is as good as you do — had Kael not jumped on the cut of the film she had seen, would the film even have been released? Paramount had pocked the film up for distribution did not like what they saw, they went back and forth with Altman on editing and he would but budge — when Kael’s review came out, they backed off and released the film as Altman intended — in a Playboy magazine interview in 1976, Altman admits that both he and Paramount expected the film to be a blockbuster!! — I think you might not be fully aware of the immense power Kael possessed in the sixties and seventies, she could make or break a film, ask director SIdney J. Furie — Gable and Lombard tests higher than any Universal film ever had at that point in hstory, then Kael kills it, and the film fails — she wielded enormous power –
John H. Foote(Quote) (Reply)
Isaac — thanks for the comments and criticism — admittedly my rage at Oscar slights, or what I perceive to be slights does get the better of me sometimes — this is however an awards discussion site, correct? — on Coppola losing the Oscar — he had won the DGA for Best Director, winning over Fosse I might add, so I might use the same logic against you — you claim because Cabaret (1972) took eight Oscars that Fosse was deserving — if Cabaret (1972) won so many Oscars how did it lose Best Picture?? For me the Best Film is also the Best Directed, it just makes sense because the director is the cheif creative force of the film, everything goes through them — now I happen to love Cabaret (1972) in fact it is the finest musical ever made, but no chance do I believe that Fosse’s direction of that film was superior to Coppola’s of The Godfather (1972).
John H. Foote(Quote) (Reply)
I…still don’t understand. Is it really “out of line” for me to interpret a negative opinion of other film critics from you? Your follow-up comment seems to confirm that impression, so I don’t see where I was off. Yes, Badlands, A Clockwork Orange and The Piano all “had their detractors,” but you are making the claim that the ONLY reason Nashville enjoyed such a healthy critical reputation was because of Kael, and that’s just not supported by her career. I have no doubt that she played a part in its release, or that Paramount wasn’t happy with Altman’s cut, but I don’t see how that’s relevant to your point, especially considering the number of amazing motion pictures that have also suffered torturous production/release histories (Margaret being a very recent example).
I remember on your previous Best of the Decade article citing Bonnie and Clyde as a 60’s masterpiece. How would you have responded if I claimed that that film was beloved only because Roger Ebert’s “minions” fell in line behind him on it? I’m just trying to understand where you’re coming from.
Robert Hamer(Quote) (Reply)
It’s sad to think that although all 5 of his films received nominations for Best Picture (and 3 won), John Cazale wasn’t nominated one. I think he should have been nominated (and won) for Supporting Actor for The Godfather Part II
Joe G(Quote) (Reply)
Robert, if you don’t get the point, you are never going to get it — as usual we agree to disagree — there is a great book about the history of the making of Nashville, send me your address and I will send it along to you — you should read it and perhaps then understand the staggering impact Kael had on this film.
John H. Foote(Quote) (Reply)
John, the disagreement has nothing to do with whether or not Kael influenced the release of Nashville. I’m fairly aware of how my third-favorite movie of all time came to fruition, and it’s hardly unusual for a single critic or group of critics to spark widespread critical approval of an initially overlooked film.
Where I’m asking for clarification – in as accommodating a manner as I can – is your notion that she and she alone is responsible for its subsequent arthouse respect, which sounds on its face like a rather personal dismissal of the critical bonafides of other fans of Altman’s masterpiece, and I know you wouldn’t actually go there.
And while I do appreciate your offer to send me reading material, I’m a little bogged down in SWO literature at the moment and I don’t think I can make the time.
Robert Hamer(Quote) (Reply)
in no particular order;
THE EXORCIST
GODFATHER PART II
NASHVILLE
CARRIE
PAPER MOON
THE LAST PICTURE SHOW
DON’T LOOK NOW
ALL THE PRESIDENTS MEN
DOG DAY AFTERNOON
HAIR
Inkdrone(Quote) (Reply)
Best decade for film ever. Ever.
1. The Godfather
2. Star Wars
3. The Godfather Part 2
4. One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest
5. Chinatown (all 5 in my top 20 films ever)
6. Apocalypse Now
7. Jaws
8. Taxi Driver
9. A Clockwork Orange
10. The Deer Hunter (all ten in my top 43 ever)
Just an incredible decade.
Mark Johnson(Quote) (Reply)
1970′s was the “woody allen decade”
randall g gerber(Quote) (Reply)
I don’t know about that, Randall…if the seventies was Woody Allen’s decade, that what would you call the eighties? That decade gave us The Purple Rose of Cairo, Hannah and Her Sisters, Another Woman *and* Crimes and Misdemeanors.
Robert Hamer(Quote) (Reply)
The 1970s has never been one of my favorite decades. “I Remember”, it always seemed a little thin in quality in proportion to the number of films being made, but in looking back, the decade unfolded as the mother lode of many great personal films. It was the decade Hollywood finally sat up and realized that small, independent, socially conscious art films geared to a younger audience could make money “Easy Rider” being the “the turning point”. As a result the movies grew up. A lot of great new directors, writers and actors were hitting big strides. It was the time we discovered “The Flying Nun” was a revelation in “Sybil”; Ingmar Bergman made two great films, “Cries and Whispers”, “Autumn Sonata, and, alas one of his worse while in self-exile from his native Sweden, “The Serpent’s Egg”; a movie that was shaped and succeeded on its music, “Saturday Night Fever”; and two of the weirdest movies in filmdom were introduced and eventually developed a cult following: “Demon Seed” with Julie Christie, and David Lynch’s freshman effort, “Eraserhead”.
And so to the list (and this one was extremely difficult to do). These were the ones that stayed with me.
1. Chinatown (Roman Polanski)
2. Cabaret (Bob Fosse)
3. Close Encounters of The Third Kind (Steven Spielberg)
4. Barry Lyndon (Stanley Kubrick)
5. The Go-Between (Joseph Losey)
6. Harold and Maude (Hal Ashby)
7. The Exorcist (William Friedkin)
8. Nashville (Robert Altman)
9. A Clockwork Orange (Stanley Kubrick)
10. Jaws (Steven Spielberg)
11. The Godfather (Francis Ford Coppola)
12. Annie Hall (Woody Allen)
13. Star Wars (George Lucas)
14. Taxi Driver (Martin Scorcese)
15. Young Frankenstein (Mel Brooks)
16. Honorable Mentions: Apocalypse Now (Coppola), Don’t Look Now (Nicholas Roeg)MASH (Altman), Midnight Express (Al Parker), What’s Up Doc? (Bogdonavich) Walkabout (Roeg), Sleeper (Allen), Picnic At Hanging Rock (Weir), Days of Heaven (Malick), Heaven Can Wait (Beatty), Frenzy (Hitchcock).
Guilty Pleasures: Hair, Grease, The Poseidon Adventure, Jesus Christ Superstar, Blazing Saddles, That’s Entertainment!, Tommy, Carrie, The Last Wave, Mad Max, The Goodbye Girl, Logan’s Run.
Foreign Films:
1. Seven Beauties (Wertmuller)
2. La Cage Aux Folles (Molinari)
3. Amarcord (Fellini)
4. That Obscure Object of Desire (Buñuel)
5. The Discrete Charm of the Bourgeosie (Buñuel)
6. Day for Night (Truffaut)
7. Cries and Whispers (Bergman)
8. The Story of Adele H. (Truffaut)
9. Autumn Sonata (Bergman)
10. The Marriage of Maria Braun
Thank you for doing these lists. It’s wonderful to look back and a lot of fun. Thank you for your indulging my lengthy entry.
jmlatinsir(Quote) (Reply)
Easily the best decade in film yet.
All of these are in my top 100 films of all time.
1. One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest
2. Taxi Driver
3. Barry Lyndon
4. Annie Hall
5. Chinatown
6. The Godfather
7. Star Wars
8. Blazing Saddles
9. Network
10. Apocalypse Now
Holden(Quote) (Reply)
1. The Godfather & The Godfather Part II
2. Network
3. Five Easy Pieces
4. Dog Day Afternoon
5. Alice doesn’t live here anymore
6. The Last Detail
7. The Texas Chainsaw Massacre
8. Lenny
9. Apocalypse Now
10. And Justice for All/ Chinatown
Rohit Ramachandran(Quote) (Reply)