Film Review: ‘The Mountain Between Us’ Orchestrates a Weak Story and Wasted Talent


You can’t see a more stiff, less inspired direction than what is witnessed in Hany Abu-Assad’s “The Mountain Between Us.”  Adapted by J. Mills Goodloe (“Pride” and “Everything, Everything”) and Chris Weitz (“About a Boy”), it’s shocking that these two talents would construct such a mundane, overly sappy romantic piece with a tale of survival as the backdrop.  Pencil that in with the waste of two of today’s most gifted actors, Idris Elba and Academy Award winner Kate Winslet, and you have eye-rolling becoming a new Olympic sport by the end credits.

“The Mountain Between Us,” tells the story of Ben (Elba) and Alex (Winslet), two strangers that become stranded after a tragic plane crash.  Together, they must forge a connection to survive the extreme elements of a remote snow-covered mountain.  When they realize help is not coming, they embark on a perilous journey across the wilderness.

The first half of the film offers up an interesting premise and frames it in an engaging manner.  When the film is a survival story, it works itself into a comfortable pocket.  Elba’s reserved and cautious doctor is convincing while Winslet’s overzealous journalist is a plausible part of the equation.  The second the writers and director take pages from a Nicholas Sparks novel, it slides from reasonable to absurdity.

Turning the film into a ponderous love story was the wrong move.  We witness an engaged woman, with a large leg wound, become one of the most unlikable figures this year.  Alex is constantly complaining, finding herself in peril, and cause more trouble than what is warranted, even in the wilderness.

The couple’s connection is supposed to be this big, heart-rendering surprise, but when you figure it out early on, everything rings false.  The film even skews towards the most unearned ending since “Pompei” offered us a couple hugging in ashes.  Where we thought we were getting something more towards 1993’s “Alive,” we got something more towards “The Last Song” in the cold.  Never for a second do you believe that these two would hook up in the wilderness, following a fall into an icy pond, and in a very convenient magical log cabin that appears for the purpose of lovemaking on an old bed.

The good you can take with you is the superior shots by cinematographer Mandy Walker, who continues to frame scenes with grace and excitement, even if the material is floundering.  However, whoever gave her the go-ahead to end a movie with two close up shots of two people walking away from each other before charging back for a less than romantic kiss should be banished.

If you’re looking for a first date night movie, “The Mountain Between Us” will give you plenty to talk about afterward. It also reaffirms that you two just witnessed, for the first time in movie history, Dermot Mulroney is not the dick, and get’s screwed over by his fiancee.  That’s a win, right?

“The Mountain Between Us” is distributed by 20th Century Fox and is currently in theaters.

GRADE: (★)

Check out the newest Oscar Predictions and see where “THE MOUNTAIN BETWEEN US” ranks!



Previous articleNYFF Film Review: Ethan Hawke Ponders Big Questions in ‘First Reformed’
Next articleFilm Review: ‘Blade Runner 2049’ Maximizes Its Worth with Stunning Direction and Camera Work
Clayton Davis--prolific writer and autism awareness advocate of Puerto Rican and Black descent, known for his relentless passion, dedication, and unique aptitude. Over the course of a decade, he has been criticizing both film and television extensively. To date, he has been either featured or quoted in an array of prominent outlets, including but not limited to The New York Times,, Variety, Deadline, Los Angeles Times, FOX 5, Bloomberg Television, AOL, Huffington Post, Bloomberg Radio, The Wrap, Slash Film, and the Hollywood Reporter. Growing up in the Bronx, Clayton’s avid interest in the movie world began the moment he first watched "Dead Poets Society” at just five years of age. While he struggled in English class all throughout grade school, he dived head first into writing, ultimately taking those insufficiencies and transforming them into ardent writings pertaining to all things film, television, and most importantly, the Academy Awards. In addition to crafting a collection of short stories that give a voice to films that haven’t made it to the silver screen, Clayton currently serves as the Founding Editor of He also holds active voting membership at various esteemed organizations, such as the Broadcast Film Critics Association, Broadcast Television Journalists Association, African-American Film Critics Association, New York Film Critics Online, Black Reel Awards, and International Press Academy. Furthermore, Clayton obtained his B.A. degree in American Studies and Communications.