in ,

Awards: Did PGA And SAG Clear Anything Up For Oscar?

best movies 2019 main duo 1b scaled

In the blink of an eye, the Oscar race has changed once again. Going into last weekend, it seemed like Quentin Tarantino‘s awards friendly period piece “Once Upon a Time…in Hollywood” had the inside track for Best Picture. It appeared to be the front runner, buoyed in part by its presumed favorite status to win the top prizes at the Producers Guild Awards and the Screen Actors Guild Awards. Then, the ceremonies actually happened, hitting the reset button on an already chaotic season.

The Producers Guild of America and the Screen Actors Guild are two of the most important and influential Oscar predictors. PGA has predicted over twenty of the past 30 Best Picture picks by the Academy, while SAG has been right only about half the time during its existence. Neither on their own are lock down wins for a contender, but it’s hard to win without at least one. Win both and you’re sitting pretty. Obviously, that didn’t happen this year, and in fact, both Guilds had upset victors, setting the stage for Oscar night to be a photo finish.

PGA gave their top prize to Sam Mendes‘ “1917,” arguably making it the new front runner in Picture. A traditional yet visually stylish contender, there’s clearly going to be crossover between the Producers and the Academy. Prior to this win, the film seemed like a top tier player, but maybe more likely to see Mendes win Best Director than the movie itself to take Picture. Now, it has skyrocketed to the forefront of the race.


“1917” can take that win, merge it with a Golden Globe victory, and claim to have put “Once Upon a Time…in Hollywood” pretty much in the rear view mirror. Going into SAG, it was just a matter of seeing how that Guild voted. Would they try to revive Tarantino’s movie? Or, would they put forward a new challenger?

SAG did two very different things. On the acting side, they confirmed that the four likely Oscar winners are now all but assured of golden statues. You can basically mark it down. Joaquin Phoenix is winning Best Actor for his work in “Joker.” Renee Zellweger is taking Best Actress for her performance as the title character in “Judy.” Brad Pitt is grabbing Best Supporting Actor for “Once Upon a Time…in Hollywood.” Laura Dern is taking home Best Supporting Actress for “Marriage Story.” Unless something shocking happens, they’re set in stone. Then, the Ensemble win went to Bong Joon-Ho‘s “Parasite,” which is a whole other ball of wax.

The “Parasite” win almost certainly makes it the number two contender for Best Picture at the Oscars. Prior to this win, it seemed hard to believe that the Academy would actually pull the trigger and make history. After all, being only the twelfth foreign film ever nominated by Oscar in Picture, it would break statistics to see voters select it in the top category. SAG has spurred them to consider it even more. Between the influx of a more diverse voting body and the opportunity for another win, either at BAFTA or the Directors Guild Awards, this title could be surging at the perfect time.

AC06 dec

Of course, BAFTA and DGA still loom large. The Academy Awards for Best Picture and Best Director could hedge on which title emerges victorious from those two precursors. “1917” probably only needs one of these to cement its status as the odds on favorite. “Parasite” would need both to make a statistically backed claim to the win. Stats aren’t everything, though. A split between the two here, depending on how it would go, may foretell an Oscar split. The possibilities remain myriad.

This all sets up a fight to the finish for Best Picture at Oscar between “1917” and “Parasite.” Will the Academy go for a war film, somewhat traditionally up their alley, or will they break with tradition and go international for the first time? The safe bet is that the former comes out on top in the end. However, don’t count out the latter. We saw “Moonlight” dethrone “La La Land” only a few years ago, after all, so upsets happen. Stay tuned!

What do you think the PGA and SAG results will mean for Oscar? Let us know in the comments below! 

What do you think?

268 points
Upvote Downvote

Written by Joey Magidson

When he’s not obsessing over new Oscar predictions on a weekly basis, Joey is seeing between 300 and 350 movies a year. He views the best in order to properly analyze the awards race/season each year, but he also watches the worst for reasons he mostly sums up as "so you all don't have to". In his spare time, you can usually find him complaining about the Jets or the Mets. Still, he lives and dies by film. Joey's a voting member of the Broadcast Film Critics Association.


Notify of

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Joey Magidson

Long story short…we’re closer to answers, but not there yet.

Kenneth Stoddard

Not giving up Hollywood just yet.


The second to last paragraph is spot on.

The DGA winner is probably taking the Best Director Oscar, but I’ll only predict Parasite to win Picture if it wins both BAFTA and DGA, because I’m not messing with the PGA stats until I have a better reason to.

If 1917 wins BAFTA and Parasite wins DGA, a 1917/Bong Joon-ho split seems likely.


The DGA winner is definitely taking Director win at Oscars. I’ll predict Parasite for Best Picture over 1917 mainly due to a gut feeling. But looking at statistics, SAGs has missed more than PGA in the past decade so 1917 may very well win.


the turning main

Film Review: ‘The Turning’ Refuses to Confront Its Revelations

The Last Full Measure

Film Review: ‘The Last Full Measure’ Rests on the Shoulders of Strong Performances