OSCARS: Anticipating the Tears for Best Actor Going Into the Winter Break

timotheechalamet callme

With SAG voting firmly underway, Oscar voters are packing up for their getaways for the winter break.  Screeners are being piled up, and they look to dedicate some time to watch what they “hear is really good” and what’s going to be “in contention.”

With Golden Globes, SAG, and Critics Choice announcing their nominations, pundits, and casual awards watchers are calling several races on the face in which they stand.  Covering this beat for over ten years, we all know it’s never that simple.  We always try to be one step ahead of Oscar and anticipate those “shockers” or “WTF?” nominations that befall us nearly every year.  Like always, each category is ripe with possibilities.  Where the focus is today, is the Best Actor race.

Before SAG announced their nominations, there was a feeling of a conventional five that floated on the internet: Timothee Chalamet (“Call Me by Your Name“), Daniel Day-Lewis (“Phantom Thread“), James Franco (“The Disaster Artist“), Tom Hanks (“The Post“), and Gary Oldman (“Darkest Hour“).  SAG introduced the possibilities of Daniel Kaluuya (“Get Out“) and Denzel Washington (“Roman J. Israel, Esq.“), unleashing pandemonium in the Lead Actor race.  Not to mention that there are a few others waiting in the wings that could pop up as support builds, in particular, Christian Bale (“Hostiles“) and Jake Gyllenhaal (“Stronger“).

denzelwashingtonAnalyzing what the Best Actor race looks from the SAG perspective, it would skew unconventionally young with both Chalamet and Kaluuya on the list.  With both “The Post” and “Phantom Thread” not screening in time (or late) for SAG consideration, we have to assume that both Day-Lewis and Hanks are still in play for their nominations.  Adding in that Oldman’s work as Winston Churchill is still considered the frontrunner, now leading in critic’s prizes, that’s three spots secured.

When it comes to Washington, he’s never been nominated for both Globe and SAG and missed out on an Oscar nomination.  Sprinkle in the narrative that he’s off a huge loss last year for “Fences,” he’s looking mighty strong for a nod.  If there is a chink in his armor, he will likely not be nominated for a BAFTA award since they seem to have a strange affliction to Washington’s past roles, never nominating him before.  Add him to the mix and we’re up to four.

That leaves one spot for Chalamet, Kaluuya, and Franco.  In the case of “Call Me by Your Name,” the major SAG misses for Ensemble and Armie Hammer may show that it’s going to run into trouble with voters. I’m also of the theory that there is “Donald Trump being voted president” syndrome when it comes to Luca Guadagnino’s drama.  With critics and vocal admirers of the film being aggressive to those who don’t deem it a masterpiece, we may have an unvocal group that either doesn’t like the film or just aren’t as impressed with its overall final product.  That same group may just be sitting quietly, not sharing those feelings until it comes to time to make their choices.  We may have seen a preview of that at SAG.  There also might be a feeling that Chalamet is young, and will have plenty of time to get here again in the future.  I overhead a voter speaking of him at a screening for “All the Money in the World” and compared him to the second coming of Brad Pitt in his endless possibilities of superstardom. That could be a shared sentiment.

Daniel KaluuyaKaluuya is in a film that is well liked by critic’s and the SAG nods support that claim.  A newcomer to the Oscar game, it’ll be interesting if he can turn his momentum from BFCA and SAG to an Academy invitation for “Get Out.”  And then there’s Franco, a beloved performance on the year, in a popular film that critics and audiences are eating up.  “The Disaster Artist” seems to top out at two nods but as a former nominee for “127 Hours,” they obviously are familiar with Franco.  Not to mention that the “direct yourself to an Oscar nomination” card is quite impressive and a good one to play at any time.

James Franco 1Bottom line is that we must anticipate the falling of someone strong on the year.  To assume that those three beloved performances will undoubtedly make the lineup is foolish.  As we’ve seen in past Best Actor years where surprises occur, AMPAS goes with someone they know over a young, newcomer.  Look at Tommy Lee Jones getting nominated for “In the Valley of Elah” over Emile Hirsch in “Into the Wild” for example.  Granted, there are cases where a newcomer with a great year leapfrogs someone special.  Look at Terrence Howard getting nominated for “Hustle and Flow” over Russell Crowe for “Cinderella Man.”

With publicists and Oscar-watchers banking heavily on this new membership to change the Oscar game forever, it’ll be interesting to see what they actually choose to do when it comes to putting the pens on the ballot.

All Oscar Predictions have been updated including all the shorts, along with Visual Effects and Makeup and Hairstyling, following the bakeoff announcements.




What do you think?

268 points
Upvote Downvote
Film Buff

Written by Clayton Davis

Clayton Davis is the esteemed Editor and Owner of Born in Bronx, NY to a Puerto Rican mother and Black father, he’s been criticizing film and television for over a decade. Clayton is a member of the Broadcast Film Critics Association where he votes and attends the kick off to the awards season, the Critics Choice Awards. He also founded the Latino Entertainment Journalists Association, the first Latino-based critics’ organization in the United States. He’s also an active member of the African-American Film Critics Association, New York Film Critics Online, International Press Academy, Black Reel Awards, and the Broadcast Television Journalists Association. Clayton has been quoted and appeared in various outlets that include The New York Times,, Variety, Deadline, Los Angeles Times, FOX 5, Bloomberg Television, AOL, Huffington Post, Bloomberg Radio, The Wrap, Slash Film, and the Hollywood Reporter.


Notify of

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Christian Palmer

Unless I missed a precursor, Chalamet actually has more wins in critics prizes.

Chalamet – NYFCC, LAFCA, Boston Online, Chicago, Phoenix, Kansas City
Oldman – LA Online, D.C., St. Louis, New York Online, Southeast

In addition, Chalamet has more nominations than Oldman- 17 to 16, although that does count Indie Spirit for Chalamet. Although to counter that, that count also includes Oldman’s IGN nomination, which isn’t technically a critics prize, making the final count still Chalamet (16) over Oldman (15).

This is, unless, I’ve missed some precursors.

Michael Eduard Gschwandtner

Though CMBYN missed Ensemble, Chalamet got his nomination. I guess they might not have agreed on one supporter, splitting votes for Hammer and Stuhlbarg. I think, still, that we will see Oldman, Franco both with Globe wins and Chalamet as the solid first three. They could spoiler DDL at the Globes because Oldman and HFPA are not good friends in particular. I also think that they will nominate DDL at the Oscar’s, for two reasons: 1. PTAs Phantom Thread most likely won’t score more than 2-3 other nominations (Costume, Score, maybe Production Design), giving DDL a nod seems to be… Read more »


“With critics and vocal admirers of the film being aggressive to those who don’t deem it a masterpiece, we may have an unvocal group that either doesn’t like the film or just aren’t as impressed with its overall final product. ” Lmfao


Gary Oldman and The Darkest Hour have under performed with the critics. His unpopularity in Hollywood could make him this year’s Michael Keaton – the veteran who loses to the younger, rising actor (Timothee Chalamet).


get out catherine keener

Producers Guild to Honor ‘Get Out’ With 2018 Stanley Kramer Award

Screen Shot 2017 12 21 at 2.45.46 AM

WATCH: Lisa Kudrow, Peter Gallagher Visit the Beach House in New ‘Grace and Frankie’ Trailer